39 Congdon Road Shelter Island, NY 11964

$1,495,000 4 Bedrooms3 Full Baths3,752 sq. ft.

39 Congdon Road Shelter Island, NY 11964

Shelter Island Waterfront Sanctuary
Year Built: 1924
Interior: 3,752 sq. ft. (approx.)
Land: 1.29 acres (approx.)
Web #: 0057720
Folio #: 80345
At the very end of a quiet country road there sits a stately shingle house, perched above Congdons Creek, where time seems to stand still. This property is the very embodiment of what is so special about Shelter Island, with the hustle-and-bustle of Route 27 seemingly in another world (yet only 25 minutes away by a short ferry ride). Lovingly built for himself and his family by David Dowd, of Victorian Homes, the house has been expanded, renovated and updated throughout the years, always with an eye towards engendering magical summer moments: you can watch the sunrise from the expansive deck off the Master Suite; then, from your dock on the creek, take a skiff out to tour the boats of Coecles Harbor, visit the old cottage on Taylor's Island or head out into the protected waters of Gardeners Bay; the screened porch lends itself to a quiet moment of reflection overlooking the creek at the end of the day. Or, simply step out on the back deck, where the lawn is speckled by an orchard of fruit trees, for a sunny spot to grill and eat dinner - perhaps the day's catch? Your guests enjoy a most spectacular view from the privacy of the separate apartment above the carriage house. With the possibility to expand beyond four bedrooms and with room for a pool, this is a most unique opportunity to create your own wondrous Shelter Island sanctuary.

Jonathan Smith

Licensed Salesperson
m: (917) 714-9022
o: (631) 227-4950

Lawrence Ingolia

Associate Broker, Global Real Estate Advisor
m: (516) 607-8800
o: (631) 227-4931


Interior Features

Bedroom Information
# of Bedrooms: 4
Bathroom Information
# of Full Bathrooms: 3
Design Features
Fireplace(s): 4
Hardwood Flooring
Stone Countertops
Additional Rooms
In-Law Apartment
Other Features
Hi-Speed Internet Ready

Exterior Features

Type of Property
Single Family Home
Other Features
Deck / Patio
Guest House
Pool House
Architectural Style
Creek / Canal / Inlet View
Room For Pool
Water View
This material is based upon information which we consider reliable, but because it has been supplied by third parties, we cannot represent that it is accurate or complete, and it should not be relied upon as such. This offering is subject to errors, omissions, changes including price or withdrawal without notice. EQUAL HOUSING OPPORTUNITY